USB PD Audio Accessory connection

ADoro.2 · ‎2021-02-20

I am working with demo board B-G474E-DPOW1 and the project from the STM32CubeG4 Sink examples.

I am trying to figure out how to connect an Audio Accessory. I have such an adapter. When I connect it to the usb-c, I expect to see an event with the connection of an Audio Accessory. But that doesn't happen.

_SNK and _ACCESSORY_SNK are defined.

How can I debug this event?

Yohann M. · ‎2021-02-22

Dear @ADoro.2

An accessory is a device which presents Ra resistors on each CC lines. To be sure that you are connected an audio accessory, you should check the values of resistors conneted on both CC lines. You may attach a cpd log to this thread or read directly the values of UCPD[SR] registers in the debugger, bits TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 & TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2. You should have 0 for both values.

#define LL_UCPD_SRC_CC1_VRA        0x0U                                                      /*!< CC1 Source vRA state              */
#define LL_UCPD_SRC_CC2_VRA        0x0U                                                      /*!< CC2 Source vRA state              */

Yohann

ADoro.2 · ‎2021-02-22

Bits TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 & TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2 equal 0 for both states, when nothing attached and when audio accessory attached.

In UCPD monitor nothing happens.

Is it possible to make any event on audio accessory attach?

Yohann M. · ‎2021-02-22

Hello

did you enable CAD_AccesorySupport in uspb_dpm_conf.h?

USBPD_SettingsTypeDef       DPM_Settings[USBPD_PORT_COUNT] =
{
  {
(...)
    .CAD_AccesorySupport = USBPD_TRUE,         /* cas accessory support                                   */
(...)

Yohann

ADoro.2 · ‎2021-02-23

When I enable CAD_AccesorySupport these messages are coming continuously:

713 CAD 34864 1 USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED

714 CAD 34904 1 ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E

715 CAD 34948 1 USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED

716 CAD 34988 1 ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E

717 CAD 35032 1 USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED

718 CAD 35072 1 ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E

719 CAD 35116 1 USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED

720 CAD 35156 1 ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E

721 CAD 35200 1 USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED

722 CAD 35240 1 ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E

no matter connected something to usb-c or not.

TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 & TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2 become equal to 0x2.

But nothing event happens.

In function uint32_t CAD_StateMachine_SNK(uint8_t PortNum, USBPD_CAD_EVENT *pEvent, CCxPin_TypeDef *pCCXX)

_handle->cstate always equal to USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY.

Yohann M. · ‎2021-02-23

"ERROR with Trace_CAD :0E" means USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY.

Actually, to be able to detect an accessory, we should toggle our resistors on CC lines to Rp values (function USBPDM1_AssertRp called in ManageStateDetached_SNK). It is done every 40 ms.

It is why you can see in your log a toggle from UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY to DETACHED states.

Values 2 on CC lines means 'OPEN' in source mode (equivalent of Rp resistor). If you connect an accessory, these bits should change to 0 which means RA.

Yohann

ADoro.2 · ‎2021-02-23

I see with debugger enter in function USBPDM1_AssertRp

      /* A Sink with Accessory support shall transition to Unattached.Accessory within tDRPTransition
      after the state of both the CC1 and CC2 pins is SNK.Open for tDRP - dcSRC.DRP · tDRP, or if directed.*/
      if ( (HAL_GetTick() - _handle->CAD_tToggle_start) > CAD_ACCESSORY_TOGGLE)
      {
        _handle->cstate = USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY;
        _handle->CAD_tToggle_start = HAL_GetTick();
        USBPDM1_AssertRp(PortNum);
      }

But then in CAD_StateMachine_SNK I don`t see that TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 & TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2 become equal to 0x0 on accessory attach

  case USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY:
    {
      uint32_t cc;
      cc = Ports[PortNum].husbpd->SR & (UCPD_SR_TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 | UCPD_SR_TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2);
 
 >>> here TYPEC_VSTATE_CC1 & TYPEC_VSTATE_CC2 stiil equal to 0x2 on accessory attach
 
      _handle->CAD_tDebounce_flag = USBPD_FALSE;
      if((USBPD_TRUE == _handle->CAD_Accessory_SNK) && (cc == (LL_UCPD_SRC_CC1_VRA | LL_UCPD_SRC_CC2_VRA)))
      {
        /* Get the time of this event */
        _handle->CAD_tDebounce_start = HAL_GetTick();
        _handle->cstate = USBPD_CAD_STATE_ATTACHED_ACCESSORY_WAIT;
      }

Yohann M. · ‎2021-02-25

Dear @ADoro.2

I tested again our FW in front of official tool (TC 4.4.6 SNKAS Connect Audio on Ellisys ) and I don't have issues to detect an audio accessory).

Please refer to the attached log I generated in this configuration:

4115	CAD	347188	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY
4116	CAD	347232	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED
4117	CAD	347272	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY
4118	CAD	347316	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED
4119	CAD	347356	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY
4120	CAD	347385	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_ATTACHED_ACCESSORY_WAIT
4121	CAD	347507	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_AUDIO_ACCESSORY
4122	EVENT	347507	1	EVENT_ACCESSORY
4123	CAD	348077	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_DETACHED
4124	EVENT	348077	1	EVENT_DETACHED
4126	CAD	348117	1	USBPD_CAD_STATE_UNATTACHED_ACCESSORY

If I connect also a Type-C charger to my sink device, I am able to establish a PD contract.

Can you please attach your .cpd file you can retrieve in the CubeMonitor-UCPD folder ( cpd log )?

Could you please confirm that your audio accessory is really an audio accessory from Type-C point of view? We know that few of them are not really audio accessory like described in the Type-C specification but those are legacy cables (based on the previous USB type).

Did you connect a Type-C charger to your board? Did you try it without enabling the accessory support?

Regards

Yohann

ADoro.2 · ‎2021-02-28

@Yohann M., thank you for your answers.

It looks like my audio accessory from Xiaomi is not real Type-C. There is no any connection between CC and Gnd lines.

I`ll try to make my own real accessory and then add some information here.

All other board B-G474E-DPOW1 operation with charger is OK except for what I wrote about here.