cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

ST25R200 - Antenna drive - single ended vs differential

jeferson
Associate II

Hello

 

I am beginning the electrical schematic with the ST25R200. 

I saw on the datasheet, and here:
https://eds.st.com/nfc-tuningcircuit/
I saw that there is the single-ended and differential ways / circuits to drive the antenna.
The differential circuit is bigger, it has more components.

So what I ask here is about these difference (single-ended / differential), if using the single-ended scheme it's possible to reach the same tag distance reading of the differential scheme. Because our PCB is relativelly small in space available. Are there more advantages on using the differential circuit compared to the single-ended circuit?

Regards
Jeferson Pehls.

2 REPLIES 2
Travis Palmer
ST Employee

Hi Jeferson, 

below a comparison between differential and single ended driver topology.

 

Differential (Push-Pull) Driver Topology

How it works:

The matching network is connected to a H-bridge push pull driver stage. Both outputs are actively driven: when one goes high, the other goes low, and vice versa. This creates a differential signal across the matching network and antenna.

Benefits:

Double the Voltage Swing:

The voltage across the matching network and antenna is the difference between the two outputs. If each output swings between 0 and VDD(_DR)​​, the antenna sees a swing of 2*VDD(_DR) (from +VDD(_DR)​​ to −VDD(_DR​).

The result is a higher magnetic field strength, which improves NFC communication range and reliability.

Improved Power Efficiency:

For the same supply voltage, you get more power delivered to the antenna and less power is wasted in the driver, as both sides are actively driven.

Better Common-Mode Noise Rejection:

Differential signals are less susceptible to common-mode noise (e.g., power supply noise, external EMI). This improves signal integrity and reduces the risk of communication errors.

Higher Sensitivity:

A differential signal is present on the two RFI pins resulting in twice the input voltage and higher sensitivity.

Drawbacks:

BOM:

Bigger BOM, higher costs

 

Single-Ended Driver Topology

How it works:

One end of the antenna is driven by the push pull driver, the other push pull driver can be connected to another antenna. The voltage swing across the antenna is limited to VDD(_DR)

Benefits:

Dual Antenna operation:

Two single ended antennas can be connected to most of the ST25R products. The two antennas can be operated time-multiplexed (one after the other).

Reduced BOM:

Only the half amount of components used compared to the differential antenna topology.

Drawbacks:

EMI:

Possible common mode EMI issues due to lack of differential signal.

 

Please let us know if you have further questions.

BR Travis

Brian TIDAL
ST Employee

Hi,

In addition to @Travis Palmer answer, the performances can be evaluated with the STEVAL-25R200SA discovery kit. The kit is provided with different antenna (main differential antenna and dual single antenna). The schematics and gerber files are also available for references.

Regarding your question about:

  • the typical power consumption at 3.3V: see Electrical characteristics at 3.3V table in the datasheet
  • and ways to reduce consumption: the device implements a Wake up mode for tag detection. This can be evaluated and tuned using the STEVAL-25R200SA discovery kit. When the device is not needed by the application, it can be left under RESET to minimize even more the power consumption (assuming the Reset pin is controled by the application).

Rgds

BT

 

In order to give better visibility on the answered topics, please click on Accept as Solution on the reply which solved your issue or answered your question.