MOSFET failure & protection

[ST Migration account]

This account only shares restored community content posted by members between May 22 and June 9, 2026, who did not register for the new community.

A P-channel MOSFET is currently used for switching the solenoid.

Case 1:
Is it possible for the MOSFET to fail?

Case 2:
If the MOSFET fails, will it become an open circuit or a short circuit?

Case 3:
If the MOSFET fails in short-circuit condition, how can the circuit be protected  

[TDK]

Is this a school question or an interview question?

[ST Migration account]

In automotive application we used to switch the solenoid in starter motor .

 

[Andrew Neil]

 you didn't answer the question!

[Peter BENSCH]

Welcome , to the community!

Your questions are questions about the fundamentals of electrical engineering and sound like exam questions from schools.

1. Yes, there are several reasons why the MOSFET fails
2. The impact of the failure can depend on several things: the cause of the failure, the design of the MOSFET, the board layout, etc.
3. For this specific case, only one fuse is necessary.

Is there a specific reason why youre asking this in a forum for STMicroelectronics devices?

Regards
/Peter

[ST Migration account]

In case P Channel MOSFET get fail it become open circuit or short circuit (soruce and Drain)?

[Peter BENSCH]

A fixed probability for the two cases cannot be stated without specific data. A short circuit between D-S is usually more likely in the event of overload, while an open-circuit fault is more likely if e.g. connection wires, metallisation or mechanical structures fail. The exact cause depends greatly on what the overload looks like.

In short, there can be no general answer to your question.

Regards
/Peter

[ST Migration account]

This is circuit diagram 

[ST Migration account]

My Use of MOSFET is switch the startrer motor solenoid 

If possible shortcircuit occur in source to drain ?

[Peter BENSCH]

It is not about components from STMicroelectronics, but to help the TO, here is a suggestion for where could insert the fuse mentioned: between drain/R4 and D2/SL.

[Andrew Neil]

That wasn't the question - was it?

Both  @TDK  and  @Peter BENSCH  have asked you whether this is a school or interview question.

You don't seem to be using any ST products?

[AScha.3]

Yes.

[ST Migration account]

How to protect the short circuit 

 

[Peter BENSCH]

As I already said: this case can be covered by a fuse, but it must be taken into account that it takes time to react.

A better approach than a p-channel MOSFET is an integrated power switch, which, in addition to a p-channel, also includes the corresponding protection functions. They are also available as high-side drivers for automotive and industrial applications.

Regards
/Peter

[Andrew Neil]

As  @Peter BENSCH  said, there are products specifically designed for this application - which give you protection, diagnostics, etc.

Google* "Automotive solenoid driver" or similar.

 

* other internet search engines are available