Why CubeMx cannot generate code only with CMSIS without HAL,LL? It would be very cool for the Stm32CubeMx to generate code using only CMSIS lib.

[РПосл.1]

..

[Peter BENSCH]

CMSIS only relates to the core, while HAL and LL also support the peripherals.

Regards

/Peter

[РПосл.1]

If I'm not mistaken cmsis describes not only Core. This library have structures for describe peripheral s Pozdrawiam, Raman Pasledni On 20 Aug 2021, 12:59 +0200, ST Community , wrote: CMSIS only relates to the core, while HAL and LL also support the peripherals. Regards /Peter [https://community.st.com/ncsphoto/UINeD2JN0zF5cg_LIZ7Z1WX9ZeweZNqxdzQxrFlQ4OQQwIAouzw-VWNYyB8EUVFR?fromEmail=1]<> Peter BENSCH<> (ST Employee) CMSIS only relates to the core, while HAL and LL also support the peripherals. Regards /Peter View/Answer<> or reply to this email Replying to [https://community.st.com/img/userprofile/default_profile_45_v2.png?fromEmail=1]<> РПо�?л.1<> (Community Member) asked a question. Friday, August 20, 2021 3:10 AM<> Why CubeMx cannot generate code only with CMSIS without HAL,LL? It would be very cool for the Stm32CubeMx to generate code using only CMSIS lib. [https://community.st.com/ncsphoto/UINeD2JN0zF5cg_LIZ7Z1WX9ZeweZNqxdzQxrFlQ4OQQwIAouzw-VWNYyB8EUVFR?fromEmail=1]<> Peter BENSCH<> (ST Employee) CMSIS only relates to the core, while HAL and LL also support the peripherals. Regards /Peter Friday, August 20, 2021 3:59 AM<> You're receiving emails when someone "Comments on my posts." To change or turn off ST Community email, log in<> as [e-mail]. Are notifications about this post getting annoying? Reply to this email with the word " mute ". STMicroelectronics N.V. [ST Community]

[Peter BENSCH]

Well, beside the core it also covers some serial communication and memory interfaces - but no analog peripheral, like adc, dac, comparators, opamps, temp sensor, no crypto management, no watchdog, lcd, rtc and timers.

Does it really make sense to create a program exclusively on CMSIS and not to support the other peripherals?

BTW: please do not reply by email as this creates a lot of garbage in the thread.

Regards

/Peter