[LoRaWAN_End_Node_LBM] Process join accept failed with code = 14

[lcordier]

I’m trying to make the example LoRaWAN_End_Node_LBM] work on my nucleo-wl55jc1.

For now i’ve just changed the DevEUI and AppKey in se-identity.h to match my chirpstack configuration.

I can see the join request from my object and the join accept answer of the server but here is what i see on the log of the nucleo:

LoRaWAN End Node LBM
APPLICATION_VERSION: V1.6.0
MW_LORAWAN_VERSION:  V1.1.0
MW_RADIO_VERSION:    V1.4.0
L2_SPEC_VERSION:     V1.0.4
RP_SPEC_VERSION:     V2-1.0.4
Event received: RESET
###### AppKEY:  2B:7E:15:16:28:AE:D2:A6:AB:F7:15:88:09:CF:4F:3C
###### NwkKEY:  2B:7E:15:16:28:AE:D2:A6:AB:F7:15:88:09:CF:4F:3C
###### DevEUI:      CA:FE:BA:BE:DF:70:70:35
###### AppEUI:      00:00:00:00:00:00:00:00
###### DevAddr:     DF:70:70:35
8s053:Add JOIN task
8s053: TX MNG REQ time=00008053, final_time=00010788
8s055: Next TX on freq 868100000, DR 3 
10s782: Payload: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 35 70 70 DF BE BA FE CA 76 01 0A F0 D4 25 
 size: 23 
995: TX DONE
11s041: RX1 LoRa at 4957 ms freq:868100000, DR 3, BW125, rx timeout 24 ms
244: RX DONE
16s245: RP: RX size 33
16s245: Process join accept failed with code = 14
16s245:Receive a bad packet on RX1 for stack_id = 0 continue with RX2 
16s246: RX2 LoRa at 780 ms freq:869525000, DR 0, BW125, rx timeout 196 ms
17s223: IRQ_RADIO_RX_TX_TIMEOUT
Event received: JOINFAIL

This error code 14 seem to be related to the secure element but i don’t really understand how to solve it and even what it means.

 

Do you have any idea?

 

[stm32enjoyer69]

Hello ICORDIER, 

I’m having similar issues with trying to make the example LoRaWAN_End_Node_LBM] work on my nucleo-wl55jc1. I was wondering if you ended up receiving help with this issue or if you figured it out and would be willing to share the steps to resolving the issue. 

I have attached below what I am seeing on my PUTTY.

188s692: TX DONE

188s739: RX1 LoRa at 4953 ms freq:868300000, DR 4, BW125, rx timeout 16 ms

193s827: RX DONE

193s827: RP: RX size 33

193s828: Process join accept failed with code = 14

193s828:Receive a bad packet on RX1 for stack_id = 0 continue with RX2

193s828: RX2 LoRa at 895 ms freq:869525000, DR 0, BW125, rx timeout 196 ms

194s920: IRQ_RADIO_RX_TX_TIMEOUT

Event received: JOINFAIL
 

Also here are the versions I am currently running.

LoRaWAN End Node LBM
APPLICATION_VERSION: V1.6.0
MW_LORAWAN_VERSION:  V1.1.0
MW_RADIO_VERSION:    V1.4.0
L2_SPEC_VERSION:     V1.0.4
RP_SPEC_VERSION:     V2-1.0.4
 

[RusikOk]

Hello! I’ve come across the same problem. The versions of my libraries are:

APPLICATION_VERSION: v1.6.0
MW_LORAWAN_VERSION:  v1.1.0
MW_RADIO_VERSION:    v1.5.0

In the `smtc_secure_element_process_join_accept` function in the `soft_se.c` file, I see the following code:

    // Verify mic
    if( *version_minor == 0 )
    {
        // For LoRaWAN 1.0.x
        //   cmac = aes128_cmac(NwkKey, MHDR |  JoinNonce | NetID | DevAddr | DLSettings | RxDelay | CFList |
        //   CFListType)
        if( smtc_secure_element_verify_aes_cmac( dec_join_accept, ( enc_join_accept_size - LORWAN_MIC_FIELD_SIZE ), mic,
                                                 SMTC_SE_NWK_KEY, stack_id ) != SMTC_SE_RC_SUCCESS )
        {
            return SMTC_SE_RC_FAIL_CMAC;
        }
    }
    else
    {
        return SMTC_SE_RC_ERROR_INVALID_LORAWAM_SPEC_VERSION;
    }

In other words, the v1.1.0 libraries do not support JOIN in version v1.1.0, which is very strange! So I switched the LoRaWAN version in the device settings and received the message “Event received: JOINED Modem is now joined”

I don’t know if you’re supposed to do it like that for a production

[RusikOk]

although the STs did intend to warn us:

 

[Imen.D]

Hello ​@lcordier 

Which is the complete configuration used both on LoRaWAN_End_Node_LBM and on Chirpstark?

Just to clarify, the following versions are:

• Application: LoRaWAN_End_Node_LBM (V1.6.0)   -> App version

• Middleware (MW) LoRaWAN: V1.1.0      -> LoRaWAN MW FW version

• Middleware (MW) Radio: V1.4.0             -> Radio MW FW version

• L2 Spec: V1.0.4          -> LoRaWAN Specification version v1.0.4 

• RP Spec: V2-1.0.4      -> Regional Parameters Specification version vRP002-1.0.4

 

So the LoRaWAN Specification version is v1.0.4 NOT v1.1.0.