NETXDUO lan8742 added twice to Makefile

[stst9180]

Dear community,

we're using a Makefile Project with STM32H5xx and NetX Duo using the LAN8742

When the code is generated, CubeMX is adding the line:

.../STM32Cube/Repository/STM32Cube_FW_H5_V1.1.1/Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742/lan8742.c \

twice to the Makefile which leads to multiple definition errors in Compile.

The line has to be removed by Hand afterwards.

I think this is malicous behaviour here.

Best Regards

Pascal

[STTwo-32]

Hello @stst9180 

I can't reproduce this problem. I'm using the last version of the STM32CubeIde (V 1.14.0). and CubeMX (V6.10.0). 

Can you give more details (screenshots, firmware versions,...) .

Best Regards.

STTwo-32

[stst9180]

I'm using CubeMX 6.1.0 and CubeIDE 1.13.2 but the version of IDE should not matter as bug is already in the cubemx-generated code. Below you see the cubemx configuration part of NETXDUO:

In ProjectManager I selected:

It seems that this one is only appearing in Makefile-Mode. Nevertheless this is needed for our project.
As I don't want to post the whole .ioc file here, I try to figure out the relevant parts:

MxCube.Version=6.10.0
MxDb.Version=DB.6.0.100
NETXDUO.ETH_ON=1
NETXDUO.IPParameters=ETH_ON,LAN_8742
NETXDUO.LAN_8742=1

NetXDuo.BSP.number=1
NetXDuo0.BSP.STBoard=false
NetXDuo0.BSP.api=BSP_COMPONENT_DRIVER
NetXDuo0.BSP.component=lan8742
NetXDuo0.BSP.condition=
NetXDuo0.BSP.instance=lan8742
NetXDuo0.BSP.ip=
NetXDuo0.BSP.mode=
NetXDuo0.BSP.name=LAN_Component
NetXDuo0.BSP.semaphore=SEMA_lan8742
NetXDuo0.BSP.solution=lan8742

ProjectManager.AskForMigrate=true
ProjectManager.BackupPrevious=false
ProjectManager.CompilerOptimize=6
ProjectManager.ComputerToolchain=false
ProjectManager.CoupleFile=true
ProjectManager.CustomerFirmwarePackage=
ProjectManager.DefaultFWLocation=true
ProjectManager.DeletePrevious=true
ProjectManager.DeviceId=STM32H563VITx
ProjectManager.FirmwarePackage=STM32Cube FW_H5 V1.1.1
ProjectManager.FreePins=false
ProjectManager.HalAssertFull=false
ProjectManager.HeapSize=0x200
ProjectManager.KeepUserCode=true
ProjectManager.LastFirmware=true
ProjectManager.LibraryCopy=1
ProjectManager.MainLocation=Core/Src
ProjectManager.NoMain=false
ProjectManager.PreviousToolchain=STM32CubeIDE
ProjectManager.ProjectBuild=false
ProjectManager.ProjectFileName=BK_SM.ioc
ProjectManager.ProjectName=BK_SM
ProjectManager.ProjectStructure=
ProjectManager.RegisterCallBack=I2C,SPI,TIM,UART,USART
ProjectManager.StackSize=0x400
ProjectManager.TargetToolchain=Makefile
ProjectManager.ToolChainLocation=
ProjectManager.UAScriptAfterPath=
ProjectManager.UAScriptBeforePath=
ProjectManager.UnderRoot=false

VP_NETXDUO_VS_Crypto.Mode=Crypto
VP_NETXDUO_VS_Crypto.Signal=NETXDUO_VS_Crypto
VP_NETXDUO_VS_EthernetOoPhyOoInterface.Mode=LAN8742_Phy_Interface
VP_NETXDUO_VS_EthernetOoPhyOoInterface.Signal=NETXDUO_VS_EthernetOoPhyOoInterface
VP_NETXDUO_VS_NXOoCore.Mode=NX_Core
VP_NETXDUO_VS_NXOoCore.Signal=NETXDUO_VS_NXOoCore
VP_NETXDUO_VS_NetworkOoInterface.Mode=Ethernet_Interface
VP_NETXDUO_VS_NetworkOoInterface.Signal=NETXDUO_VS_NetworkOoInterface
VP_NETXDUO_VS_TLS.Mode=TLS
VP_NETXDUO_VS_TLS.Signal=NETXDUO_VS_TLS

When I now "generate code" the produced Makefile has twice the source file of the network driver:

/home/pascal/STM32Cube/Repository/STM32Cube_FW_H5_V1.1.1/Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742/lan8742.c \

/home/pascal/STM32Cube/Repository/STM32Cube_FW_H5_V1.1.1/Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742/lan8742.c \

which leads to:

usr/lib/gcc/arm-none-eabi/10.3.1/../../../arm-none-eabi/bin/ld: ../../Build/Release/lan8742.o: in function `LAN8742_RegisterBusIO':

lan8742.c:(.text.LAN8742_RegisterBusIO+0x0): multiple definition of `LAN8742_RegisterBusIO'; ../../Build/Release/lan8742.o:lan8742.c:(.text.LAN8742_RegisterBusIO+0x0): first defined here

Please tell me If I can post more needfull information. If you can't still reproduce I would generate a new project where I can post the corresponding files.

Best Regards Pascal

[STTwo-32]

It will be better if you share a .ioc file that reproduce this behavior.

Best Regards.

STTwo-32

[stst9180]

Here U R.

This is just a newly created STM32H563VIT6 with NetXDuo and ThreadX enabled and Makefile selected as output.

When generating code, the attached Makefile is the output where lines 46 && 47 show the malicous behaviour.

Best Regards

Pascal

[STTwo-32 · Accepted solution]

Thanks for bringing this issue to our attention.

I confirm this issue and I've reported internally.

Internal ticket number: 170199 (This is an internal tracking number and is not accessible or usable by customers).

PS: Issue solved on the last release of the STM32CubeMX

Best Regards.

STTwo-32

[LostIon]

This error/problem has returned on Ethernet examples in CubeMX for the STM32H573I-DK.  However the makefile looks far different and does NOT have two lines relating to LAN8742.   The error message is: ...STM32Cube/Example/Nx_MQTT_Client/Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742/lan8742.c:61: multiple definition of `LAN8742_RegisterBusIO'; ./Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742.o:C:/Users/dbaker/STM32Cube/Example/Nx_MQTT_Client/Drivers/BSP/Components/lan8742/lan8742.c:61: first defined here

I am using STM32CubeIDE 2.0.0 and STM32CubeMX 6.16.0

Suspect .ioc, and makefile (renamed to makefile.txt) attached.

[Ghofrane GSOURI]

Hello @LostIon 

Thank you for posting. 

I'm currently checking this behavior using STM32CubeIDE 2.0.0 and STM32CubeMX 6.16.0 , I will get back to you asap.

THX

Ghofrane